| This is a comparison of
a 5,000 and 10,000 watt portable generator compared to a 12,000 watt
Onan Residential Standby generator. We used our experience and costs
based on Santa Rosa, CA. Not all areas of the country will be the
same or have the same conditions.
Cost is only one
factor.
Carefully consider the safety, security, setup and storage issues shown
on the chart. Please read the summary at the end of this chart
too! Whether you agree or now we want you to be informed. No matter what
you decide to purchase we would like to have your order.
We have residential
generators from 8,000 watts (8 kW) to 45,000 watts (45 kW), in propane,
natural gas and diesel. We have portable generators from 1,000 watts (1
kW) to 15,000 watts (15 kW) in gasoline, diesel, propane and natural
gas. The majority of portable generators are gasoline powered.
We will be offering
portable kits which include a generator, transfer switch, cord and
outlet box for one low price. To see our kits click Portable Kits.
COMING SOON!
If you are
considering a portable for an RV use, see our chart at
Portable vs RV.
For more information about fuels see
Generator Fuels.
|
COMPARISON OF
CATEGORIES BETWEEN PORTABLE AND STATIONARY GENERATORS FOR HOME
STANDBY USE |
|
Category |
Typical |
Portable |
Stationary |
Winner |
|
|
|
6,000 Watts |
12,000 Watts |
Stationary |
|
Models |
Portable vs
Residential |
Winco WC6000HE |
Onan RS12000 |
Onan RS12000 |
|
Time of Need |
Usually at night, bad weather |
Must
be protected from rain. |
In
protected cabinet. |
Stationary |
|
Powers |
% of
House |
50% |
100% |
Stationary |
|
Largest Single
Load |
Due to
plug restrictions |
20
Amps |
100
Amps |
Stationary |
|
Remote
Control/Start |
Automatic Preferred |
No
Auto-start |
Auto-start Standard |
Stationary |
|
Auto Choking |
Automatic Preferred |
No
Auto-choke |
Auto-Choke Standard |
Stationary |
|
Move In/Out |
Permanent Desirable |
Required unless shelter |
Move
not required |
Stationary |
|
Setup or
Connecting |
Permanent Desirable |
Required unless shelter |
Always
Connected |
Stationary |
|
Transfer of Power |
Automatic Preferred |
Manual Only |
Automatic |
Stationary.
Automatic |
|
Unattended
Operation |
Unattended desirable |
Short Periods Only |
Runs Unattended |
Stationary |
|
Operation by
Family |
Desirable |
Usually difficult |
Automatic Operation |
Stationary |
|
Weather
Protection |
Desirable |
Requires shelter or
move out/in |
Enclosure Standard |
Stationary |
|
Security |
Desirable |
Easy to steal if
left out |
Anchored to ground |
Stationary |
|
Security During
Operation |
Highly Desirable |
Must go outside
during storm to start and refuel |
Runs Automatically |
Stationary |
|
Security Storage |
Highly Desirable |
Must keep inside and
drain fuel |
Secure Outside |
Stationary |
|
Fuel Tank Type |
Strongest Preferred |
Usually plastic
|
Usually steel
|
Stationary |
|
Fuel Tank Size |
Larger better than
smaller |
4.5 gallons |
50-100 gallons |
Stationary |
|
Run Time per Tank |
Longer is better |
at 1/2 load 11.2
hours
at full load 5 hours |
200 gallon tank
lasts 40 hours |
Stationary |
|
Refueling |
Automatic Preferred |
Every 5-11 hours @
1/2 load |
Every 40 hours |
Stationary |
|
Storage of Fuel |
Desirable, if safe |
Fuel cans outside,
not inside |
In Tank Outside |
Stationary |
|
Fuel Economy |
@ Full Load |
Poor |
Excellent |
Stationary |
|
Refueling System |
Automatic Preferred |
By hand with cans,
stop generator |
By Fuel Supplier |
Stationary |
|
Layout |
Simple is Preferred |
See
Diagrams |
See Diagrams |
Stationary |
|
Number of Parts |
Smallest number
preferred |
4, generator,
switch, outlet, cord |
2, generator &
switch |
Stationary |
|
Generator Cost |
Lower is better than
higher |
$1,918 |
$4,202 |
Stationary |
|
Transfer Switch
Cost |
Lower is better than
higher |
Gen-Tran 200600,
Manual, $235 |
Onan Indoor, 100
Amp, Automatic, $670 |
Portable,
Manual |
|
Other Parts |
Outlet box, cords,
plug |
Gen-Tran $125 |
Fuel Tank, $200 |
Stationary |
|
Estimated Install
Labor (electrician) |
Lower is better than
higher |
$500 |
$900 |
Stationary |
|
Total Initial
Cost |
Lower is better than
higher |
$2,778.00 |
$5,972, ($3,194
more) |
Portable |
|
Cost Per Hour to
Run @ 1/2 Load |
Lower is better than
higher |
0.53 gallons per
hour or $1.50 hr |
54 cu.ft/hr,
< $1.00 hour |
Stationary |
|
Estimated Life
Hours |
Longer is better
than shorter |
2,000 |
10,000 |
Stationary |
|
Years of Life |
Longer is better
than shorter |
555 |
15 |
Stationary |
|
Cost per year
life years |
Lower
is better than higher |
$574 |
$398 |
Stationary |
|
Noise |
Lower
is better than higher |
79 db(A) |
<70 db(A) |
Stationary |
|
Oil Capacity |
Larger better than
smaller |
1 Quart |
3 quarts |
Stationary |
|
Adds to value of
home? |
According to RE
appraiser |
No |
Yes 50% Minimum |
Stationary |
|
Need Permit? |
According to City of
Santa Rosa in California |
No |
Yes, $25 |
Portable |
Even though
the Portable is cheaper overall, by almost double in the 6,000 watt size
and only $3,194 more in the 12,000 watt size; you have to ask yourself,
is it worth the savings. I reality you only get 50 % of the power off a
portable because you can only get the output from one plug which is 1/2
of the generators capacity unless there is a full power plug.
If you, (or
your family members if you are out of town, sick or injured), must
struggle one time to haul the portable out, plug it in and refuel it in
foul weather at night every 4-11 hours, is it worth the difference in
savings.
Read
the list over a few times and you should conclude that unless you love
to get cold and wet, stay up late and play survivor, your better off to
have an installed system that is totally automatic.
REMEMBER:
Cost is only one factor. Carefully consider the safety, security,
setup and storage issues shown on the chart. Please read the
summary at the enc of this chart as well. Whether you agree or now
we want you to be informed. No matter what you decide to purchase we
would like to have your order.
We have
residential generators from 8,000 watts (8 kW) to 45,000 watts (45 kW),
in propane, natural gas and diesel. We have portable generators from
1,000 watts (1 kW) to 15,000 watts (15 kW) in gasoline, diesel, propane
and natural gas. The majority of portable generator are gasoline
powered.
We will be
offering portable kits which include a generator, transfer switch, cord
and outlet box for one low price. To see our kits click Portable Kits.
COMING SOON!
If you
are considering a portable for an RV use, see our chart at
Portable vs RV. For more information
about fuels see
Generator Fuels.
We have lots of
information for you. Look at all these interesting topics below.
|
Compare Convenience
and Cost - Portable vs Stationary
|
Most
people can not live comfortably without continuous,
stable electrical power. Thousands of people
purchase small electric generator sets to protect
themselves, their families and their businesses in
the likely event of power failures. Here are some
basic tips.
Portable vs. Stationary – Let’s Compare Convenience
and Cost
Although
a portable generator can be manhandled, with an
average weight of 250-300 lbs, you can't call them
lightweight. If you purchase one, make sure it comes
with a set of wheels (sometimes these are optional).
Portables are universally fueled with gasoline, a
fuel that requires safe storage and extra care in
handling. Some portables have very small fuel tanks,
so they need refueling every half hour or so. Given
the choice, go for a portable generator with at
least a 5 gal tank. And don’t forget that gasoline
doesn’t store very well and will get gummy over
time.
Portable
generator owners usually employ a series of
extension cords to connect the generator to specific
items in their house, such as a refrigerator,
lights, computer, and TV. Although this system
works, it is most practical for outages of a short
duration. Most portable generators are “rope
started”, like lawnmowers. If your wife, teenager or
elderly relative will be using the generator (not
recommended) you should go for an electric start
option, if available. As you can see, there is
essentially nothing automatic about a portable
generator.
On the
other hand, a stationary (automatic) generator
averages $5,972 - but look at the differences!
Stationary generators start at about 500 lbs and are
designed with a weather protective housing that
mounts outdoors on a level surface. Fuel is
continuously supplied via your natural gas service
or propane tank, whichever you choose. Your
electrician will “hard wire” the electrical cables
to your distribution panel (no extension cords to
deal with here).
Starting
is fully automatic. In fact, it can take just 15-30
seconds from the beginning of the power outage until
the generator is completely up and running. This
type of generator employs an automatic transfer
switch which monitors the incoming power and
switches the generator on and off as needed.
How
do you know which size generator you need?
Determining the size of your generator is all
important. Electric power is measured in watts and
1,000 watts is called a kilowatt. All electrical
appliances in your home have an electrical tag or
label on them, which states the wattage. Sometimes
the tag shows only the voltage and amperage. If this
is the case, multiply the voltage by the amperage to
get the wattage. Example: say the electrical label
on the back of your toaster reads 120 volts and 10
amps. To get the wattage, 120 V x 10 A = 1200 watts.
Since 1000 watts = one kilowatt, the load can also
be considered 1.2KW.
Add up
the wattages of the loads that you consider
essential, then multiply by 75% to account for the
fact that everything will not be on at the same
time. It’s a good idea to discuss your loads with an
electrician - he can also determine or verify your
loads easily and quickly using his ammeter.
Portable
generators usually range from 3-15KW but you can
only get 1/2 the power out of each large outlet
unless the generator has a full power plug (which is
rare). Stationary generators are in the 7-40KW or
larger range. The larger sizes are normally needed
only if you have heavy electrical loads like a large
well pump or a central air conditioner. The average
sized generator for a normal home (without a central
air conditioner) is in the 10-12KW range.
For additional information about
generators look at
About Generators
on our website.
|
|